Terrible narration!

I love this book, I read it 30 years ago and it’s one of those comfort reads. Much better than Jilly cooper’s later books but the narration is appalling. She reads everything in a slightly sarcastic manner and miss-pronounces so many words. Why not use a proper narrator? I’m annoyed at having to pay for this.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Fun nostalgia!

I read this back in the day and though its obviously very dated I still really enjoyed it. Having said that, the narration left a bit to be desired. I've found the same with other Jilly Cooper books, the narrators just don't seem to get it right. Its a shame as Jilly is my go-to comfort read..😃 Still worth a listen to me though.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

I can't believe we're not bitter.....

....if we were honestly treated like that before 2nd/3rd wave feminism. I mean, I first read this book in 1985 and it seemed rather outdated in its attitudes then. Aside from its sociology political clunkiness it does have its charms and Jilly Cooper certainly could tell a good story, even if I had to listen to it with my head in my hands. The narrator was woeful, read it as though she had not given it a read through before and often misread, misinterpreted or just plain mispronounced words, and her intonation was very flat and sing song. I wish that I had left this book as a happy memory

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

Romantic and fun

Good fun 70s romance with all the fascinating, louche characters that Jilly Cooper brings to life so well.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Shame about the narration…

I have Covid and needed a comforting old favourite to help take my mind off it. ‘Harriet’ is a well loved story and I thought I’d be gently carried away by it. Sadly, I kept being brought up short by the narrator’s poor delivery; mispronounced words, poor rhythm and flow - such a shame.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Harriet

The narration did not work - it was too aggressive, some of the words were mispronounced, and no effort was made to deliver the voice of a 5 year old girl. The story was endearing and entertaining, but not given full measure by a narrator who didn’t seem to embrace the spirit of this novel…….

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Great story. Ruined by awful narration

Loved this book as a teenager but completely ruined by the staccato forced narration. Emphasis on the wrong words in sentences which was constantly grating. Reminded me of morecambe and wise. All the right notes but in completely the wrong order.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

8 people found this helpful

great listen

I have always love these books. Great narration and very easy to listen to. Thoroughly enjoyable.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Pure nostalgia - but a delight

If you used to read Jilly from her Times column through her short novels to her sweeping Rutshire saga, this is for you. It took me right back. We all know the world is changing rapidly, but who would have imagined that life not so very long ago would sound so different?

The angst of whether or not, when and how to lose one's virginity (or keep it as a sort of wedding present for your new husband); today's generation might find that baffling. Ditto the attitudes towards an unmarried mother... Particularly from Harriet's own middle class, bridge playing, what will the neighbours say, ghastly mother.

Poor old Harriet gets the lot landed on her, along with a lovely baby son and no means of supporting him. But this is Jilly land, so we all know that the whole thing will be fun, life will fall into place and Harriet will live happily ever after in the end. And she does, but along the way we can enjoy life with some typical Cooper characters.

This book, along with the other shorter novels like Imogen and Octavia (my favourites, please, Audible) could work for more than one generation. For those of us who read them when they first came out, pure nostalgia: for younger generations a window into a world their mothers and/or grandmothers knew that is really not so long ago - but seems far, far away.

PS to Audible; thrilled that you seem to be recording more of Jilly's books, but why oh why, if you have Nos 1, 9 and 10 of the Rutshire Chronicles already recorded, is the 'coming soon' one Polo, which is No 3? What happened to No 2?

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

not worth any stars really

Poor, waste of relaxation time. A storyline not a book, poor writing. Never read one before, certainly won't bother in future.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!