Excellent and illuminating.

I really enjoyed this incredibly detailed history of Marie Antoinette’s life, which dispels many of the myths surrounding her. It is wonderfully written by Antonia Fraser who succeeds in keeping one’s interest throughout.

I thought that Eleanor Bron did a magnificent job in narrating such a long book. I was a little concerned about some of the reviews I had read before purchasing the book about poor French pronunciation but nothing stood out for me, which may something about my knowledge of the language.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Spoiler alert: A life of two halves

A very informative, interesting, thought-provoking, and moving account of someone crushed by one of the great events of political history.
She led a charmed life, then a cursed one.
Then, seemingly, every imaginable cruelty was inflicted upon her.
Of course, hers was not the only tragedy at this time, and many of the revolutionaries were also victims of their own revolution. However, her story goes from one extreme to the other.
Unfortunately, she still seems to be (deliberately) misunderstood today. Additionally, then as now they had fake news, the difference is that trolling was not done online.
Plus ca change ...
Of course, the book is sympathetic to her, but there can be little doubt that she was the victim of appalling injustice, and there is surely no longer the need to take sides. You can broadly support the revolution and gasp at the stupidity, cruelty, and criminality that came with it.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Superb work by Ms Fraser

A balanced biography of profound historical value for those that can appreciate the gravitas of unlocking the veracity of tumultuous past events!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Foot notes please.

Some translations and explanation Would be appreciated. Unlike the printed version it’s difficult to constantly pause and research the French quotes.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Monumental biography

A lot of research and collating of information has gone into this comprehensive account of the life this ill-fated queen. It's an engrossing story particularly the second half of the book when her life is so inextricably part of the French Revolution. In many ways it's a sad story of a young girl destined from birth to be a pawn in international relations with little choice in her life. Her demonization whipped up in the minds of the public by scurrilous pamphlets promulgating rumours and lies reminds one that falsehoods 'going viral' is not just a feature of modern society and social media. The French court of Louis 16th in many ways contributed to their own demise by outrageous extravagance and cronyism: behaviour rather air-brushed out of the biography by the author. While It was understandable why ordinary French people wanted to be rid of the Monarchy it's regrettable that it led to such savagery and so many deaths. There's no doubt that Marie Antoinette became a scapegoat and, for all her faults, didn't deserve the humiliating way she was treated at the end nor the travesty of her 'trial' . The latter a dark stain on the reputation of the leaders of the revolution.
I thought Eleanor Bron an excellent narrator of this long recording.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Fantastic!

For someone who is deeply passionate about real stories from the past, true historical characters and real "drama" this was a delight, I remember first being faced with this book when doing a project for my history class back in school, truth be told it was difficult to get through the whole thing due to the fact that my English wasn't as good back then and all the French names confused my pace of read, but it was very refreshing to reattempt my read via the audio channel, the actress did a fantastic job at pronouncing all of the names and keeping up a pleasant steady pace while sounding clear and informative.

I believe that Antonia Fraser's fame speaks for itself when it comes to historic proficiency so I have no doubt that her account of the life of Marie Antoinette was as accurate as can be given the evidence still prevailing today, I read somewhere that Antonia tries to push her own defensive opinion about the queen of France but I found that while yes, Antonia's position definitely hinges on moral redemption of the queen's character it was not at all unjustified and the evidence presented is not told with an agenda of influencing or changing anyone's opinion. The biography is told matter-of-factly in supported on primary and secondary historical evidence and put together into a dramatic storyline of the rise and fall of Marie Antoinette, the final analysis at the end provides a great deal of context for lingering questions of the consequence of these events on history which was incredibly informative.

Thank you Antonia, I Shall look out for more books from you :)

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Marvellous

Epic account of MA’s life and steadily read by Eleanor Bron! I found myself completely immersed in this audiobook and as I tend to listen to Audible when I’m driving, walking or in bed, Marie Antoinette was with me for a couple of weeks!!!!!
I love historical biographies and highly recommend this book for its in depth research and fantastic narration! I knew little about this particular part of french history and on finishing this book now feel rather sad for her

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Worth a listen

An empathic look at Marie Antoinette and her husband. Even though the ending is known, the build-up to her execution was still sad.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

great book

great book, very well researched and a great insight into one of histories most vilified characters. incredibly well read. highly recommended.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

History well researched & told; voice falls short

What made the experience of listening to Marie Antoinette the most enjoyable?

Fraser has done her homework, giving a full, humane and insightful account of her subject's upbringing and character. Her contextual information (politics, family power-plays, protocol, international relationships, etc) ensures the reader is aware of the wider world surrounding the individual woman, whom she has brought vividly to life.

What did you like best about this story?

As well as being sound in her research, Fraser writes well, and she is especially deft and assured in describing (with occasional, appropriately-pitched speculation) the wide-ranging and increasingly severe political pressures gathering around her young subject.

What about Eleanor Bron’s performance did you like?

Bron's enunciation is excellent, and her distinctive voice should be perfect for the book. She is known to be a fine actor, but in this performance she disappoints: at times she seems to be keeping an eye on the clock, for she maintains a pace that does not allow timely pauses at sensitive moments. To this somewhat relentless 'drive' she adds at many times a rather strident pitch. The overall effect is recitation rather than narration, and it intrudes into the story. Disappointing.

Any additional comments?

Still worth buying and listening to, for the story is solid and well told, and Bron's telling of it is certainly good enough; just wish it were better.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

6 people found this helpful