Civil war

The chapters were too long.
The story was very compelling giving an interesting insight to the war from both sides. An important time in England’s history well told.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

007 with added swashbuckle

Any additional comments?

Loved this, have no idea if the Inspectorate General for Scrutiny and Survey is real but I really hope it is! Convoluted plot, lots of action and great characters. I mostly thought I knew what was going on, turns out I was mostly wrong but everything became clear in the end. Will be listening to this and any others in the series over and over again. Loved it

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

This is how an audio book should be...

The reader has an excellent and consistent range of voices and characters. He injects excitement where necessary and really makes you feel you are in the mind of the characters.

I have listened to many books over the past few years and the majority feel rushed and contain mispronunciation and inconsistencies. Not so here. The story and writing style are excellent and you really get the sense the reader knows what he is about.

If you like historic fiction, this book is a great pleasure to experience!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

A difficult listen

Would you recommend this book to a friend? Why or why not?

No. I might recommend it to read on paper (with a warning about the style) but couldn't recommend it as an audiobook. It's one of the few books that I find doesn't work as a reading despite the best efforts of the very good narrator.

Would you recommend Traitor's Field to your friends? Why or why not?

As already explained.

Have you listened to any of Cameron Stewart’s other performances? How does this one compare?

This is my first book read by Cameron Stewart so I cannot compare. However, I think he did a very good job and has a very pleasant reading voice with a good range of accents and tones of voice.

Did Traitor's Field inspire you to do anything?

I might read other books about the period but will choose carefully after this experience.

Any additional comments?

I have had this book in my library for over a year and I have lost count of the number of times I started it and gave up and had to start again. I made myself stick with it and listened to nothing else for two weeks so it was a chore and not enjoyable.


The problem is with the first half, which is so disjointed and all of the characters are so shadowy that I found it impossible to get embroiled. Scene setting and a mysterious tone are all very fine but I missed any form of narrative drive or any character I could fully engage with until 10 hours into the reading. It finally took off when it became clear who the two main characters are and what the thing is that will pitch them against each other. They may be on opposing sides of the civil war but it still needs a specific bone of contention and at last we had it over half way through.


The other thing which makes it a difficult listen, as distinct from a read, is that there are regular quotations from contemporary documents, including the numerical references and the library where they are stored. The eye can skate over the references on the page but they intrude into a reading and destroy the mood of the piece.


I have seen other reviews suggesting that readers who enjoy Hilary Mantel's books may get on better with the style of this book. All I can say is that this did not apply in my case. I would count Wolf Hall amongst my favourite reads and listens of all time but that did not mean I enjoyed this listen. The difference was in the strong character at the heart of Wolf Hall, right from the the opening sentence, which this book lacks.


My overall feeling is that is just too driven by the source documents and the attempt to turn raw information and hints about people iinto a compelling novel has not quite succeeded.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

Good listen

If you could sum up Traitor's Field in three words, what would they be?

Interesting, entertaining, informative.

What did you like best about this story?

Very interesting, I learnt a lot about the civil war without it being dry.
The main characters developed as the story went on.

What about Cameron Stewart’s performance did you like?

Well read, would listen to more of his performances.

Any additional comments?

I have listened to another book by this author and would recommend that as well.
They both give a depth to history and are entertaining. They can be slow in places but definitely are well worth listening to.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A nice surprise.

At first I wasn’t impressed with the reader. I thought he read to slowly and was dull but after a few hours listening I changed my mind. His steady pace suits the complicated plot because the listener needs some time to digest the onion layers of fact and speculation. He has a very clear voice for each character which helps to identify who’s who in a world where half the people are named after English counties.

The story is nice and deep with lots to get your teeth stuck in to. I would recommend it to any one who likes Tinker Taylor solider spy. Or Len Deghton books.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Civil War spies

It is strange to have a Government Department as protagonist in a series - the Comptrollerate-General for Scrutiny and Survey. In this volume there is the problem of both Royalists and Parliamentarians wanting to have access to such a department. This is beautifully read.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A confusing book that left me feeling frustrated

What would have made Traitor's Field better?

If the author had defined his characters better rather than let several of them morph into each other. The plot and style of writing was far too confusing for an audio book as it doesn't allow you to flick back to review chapters already read.

Would you ever listen to anything by Robert Wilton again?

Sadly not, he try's to write in a style similar to Hilary Mantel buts sadly fails

How did the narrator detract from the book?

He didn't , he tried his best with the material given

You didn’t love this book--but did it have any redeeming qualities?

No not really. I generally enjoy listening to audio books but could not wait to finish this one. The only redeeming quality it had was that I felt the need to finish it rather than feel I'd wasted money

Any additional comments?

If you like books set during The English Civil War try Bleeding Land by Giles Kristian first

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!