Would love this to be mandatory read in schools!

An amazing book celebrating men whilst confronting the dangerous impact and power of a mean minority.

Thank you for holding women to account too!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

Mind opened

As a man, we want an expert to explain stuff to us. Turns out Caitlin may be one of those experts. Fact based and source driven data (real mens opinions). My eyes were opened, and thoughts provoked. Porn, lady parts, relationships, and my struggles to seek help all explored.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

its about time...

I think what's discussed in this book is vital for anyone raising boy's .

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Catlin delivers a wonderful snapshot of how life is for men.

Catlin moran.....fabulous as always.....I loved all of this....I don't think anyone else could have delivered such amazing insights...I was so disappointed to have missed her promotion of this book in Dublin 2023.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Challenged my thinking

This was well researched in the main and very refreshing. It does present the world a bit too much through a liberal, middle class lens. And it’s a bit crude for my taste. But there is no doubt this, like all of her books, is a work of art and has the power to help us be better humans.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Brilliant!!

I'm 65 & wish I had this to read when I was 30!! Thanks

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Interesting, thought provoking & funny!

A great listen for everyone regardless of gender! Note: it didn’t bother me much, but she does swear a lot.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Laugh out loud, disgusting, thought provoking

I had to think carefully about scoring for this book. It’s a five or it’s a one – there’s no in between. In parts, quite brilliant; in other parts, offensive and angry.

Was it a five?
There were loads of laugh-out-loud moments. The humour from taking things out of context can be eye wateringly funny and she skillfully used it to illustrate some absurdities of maleness as she saw it. And my goodness, she’s a good presenter. Great voice, fearless and sounds full of fun.
The limitations of her “research” was cheerfully admitted, generalisations occasionally fessed up to and the contempt and disregard for context were generally wittily applied.
In a way, the foul language was a bit funny because it was so unexpected and confidently stated, coming as it was from a grown up woman who was taking great pleasure in shocking people by ignoring such outdated tropes as standards. (I did ponder whether the freedom to do just that after 50 years of feminism has actually improved anyone’s quality of life, but that’s by the by. I wasn't going to allow it to ruin my enjoyment, much as I hate bad language from anyone.)
Even the rants were sort of OK because she clearly had something to say, rather than simply stating over and over that men are twats without any evidence at all. And she did raise some great questions that got me thinking really deeply.

Or was it a one?
If you’re sensitive, she just spewed out poorly researched opinions, generalizing horribly and disregarding context to continually stress the point that the problem with men in general starts with the fact that, well, they’re not women.
There were three or four enjoyment-sapping rants around feminism and how rubbish blokes can be, including rounding on two named individual males by picking a couple of sentences out of context and talking as if they completely defined the men’s lives and attitudes. In those latter cases, my irritation at the rants was eased by her eventual conclusion that they weren’t worth listening to because they haven't written about the joys of having a really good poo, which is what a sassy female writer would write about. Hearing that conclusion drawn with such certainty made it obvious that the book isn’t one that should be taken too seriously.
Up until that point, I had been thinking that if I wanted to listen to moronic swearing and banter about lady parts, periods and tits then I could go to a football match or sit near a hen party after 9 p.m. But some of the questions she was raising – wow, they could open up some doors into my soul.

Ultimately, I gave it a very strong 5.

This was primarily because she asked some interesting questions that could start some much-needed conversations. And the final chapter was a belter. All the abrasive dismissals, anger and frustration that came through earlier in the book was replaced by a much softer recognition that actually, there are some good things about men. It came as a really pleasant surprise to me.

Enjoy the book for what it is. It’s very witty. Just don’t start reading it if you’ve got a sensitive man head on or you’re expecting fairness, because that’s not something that good comedy delivers.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Caitlin does it again!

Another brilliant book by Caitlin Moran - opening up a crucial and under-discussed topic. Uncomfortable but essential listening.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Everyone should listen to this book!!!

I absolutely loved this - I cried so many happy, sad and enlightened tears - it really is a fabulous piece of work and done with such a lightness of touch, I could’ve listened to hours more, Caitlin for PM!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!