Ashley covers the case of Becky Marzo, who vanished in 2003. After a concerning, yet humorous headline, Cody covers the unsolved murders of Harvey and Jeannette Crewe.

Cody tells the story of a gruesome, unsolved fate of Katarzyna Zowada in Poland. After a very threatening headline, Ashley goes over the limited information in the case of missing person, Betty Fran Smith.

Ashley opens the episode with the horrific case of Brittney Woods, whose home life and disappearance are extremely tough to listen to. After a brief headline, Cody tells of the unsolved murder of adult film producer and star William Arnold Newton, who just might be the victim of an infamous serial killer.

Cody opens with the details of Janet Smith's unsolved murder in 1920's Vancouver, Canada. After a brief, but lit, headline, Ashley covers the missing person's case of Shannon LaBau, from February 1999.

This week, Ashley opens with the puzzling case of Ashley Fuller Reed's disappearance shortly after meeting with a man at IHOP. Then, Cody covers the crazy crimes, and unreal life of Peter Gibb. After such a drastic, eventful life, his death will remain unsolved after the simplest incident allegedly led to his death.

Cody begins the episode with a hilarious job application story, as well as the puzzling unsolved murder of Terri (Missy) Beavers in 2016. So many things shock and puzzle us in her case. A couple of unfortunate, criminal female-empowered headlines later, and Ashley covers the disappearance of Bethany Markowski, who went missing in March 2001.

Ashley starts us off with the bizarre disappearance of Ellabeth Mae Lodermeier, in the early months of 1974. What would be found later that year, and then 18 years later? We go beyond the caution tape with our hilarious headline. Then Cody unravels the unusual details in the case of four members murdered in the Setagaya family, just outside Tokyo, the day before New Year's Eve of 2000.

Merry Christmas Eve! *Warning* No editing has been done to audio, in effort to get it out sooner. Ashley and Cody unravel the festive and not-so-jolly headlines that come about this time of year. Headline-only episode this week. But believe us, these are some unreal stories, including Cody's sketchy family vacation tradition?