Best Murakami For Some Time

Confession: I am a Murakami addict, owning all the work in English that I can get hold of by him.. although some I don't like so much, while some I love. Murakami's short stories are his best format, in my view: in twenty or so pages he spins out a whole world with the greatest skill, in terms of 'where is this taking me', complex time-structure of the story, immersive language, many currents of thought lying beneath the calm surface.

'First Person Singular' starts and ends with a story about how each of us can deal with the complexities and ambiguities of life - first story offers a way to overcome, last story paints a picture of the awfulness that comes from being overwhelmed. In between, the themes include those that Murakami keeps returning to as essential: ambiguity, dreams vs waking life, memory, time, guilt, connection with others, physicality, death, aloneness, and.. writing. Take 'Charlie Parker Plays Bossa Nova' for example: the narrator recalls writing a spoof review years ago of Charlie 'Bird' Parker coming back from oblivion to make a new recording in a style the opposite of his usual bebop style. The words of that review (repeated in the story) enable us to imagine just such a thing, even though on multiple levels it is impossible - Bird is dead, it's not his style, the record does not actually exist, etc - but in this story, it is possible, thanks to the power of words and the effect they have in our minds as we read. In the few pages of the story, there is a final surprise twist that adds to the question of 'what is being alive, what is being not-alive?' Like all stories here, it seems to me to be a masterpiece - just like Bird's performances - and up there with After The Quake (not on Audible, sadly - why not?) and some of The Elephant Vanishes.

There are a few 'tanka' poems included in On A Stone Pillow, my favourite being: 'The present moment / if it is the present moment / can only be taken / as the inescapable present. In the mountain wind / a head cut off / without a word / June water / at the roots of / a hydrangea'. I'm still puzzling that one out, with multiple possible solutions.

As for the review elsewhere likening these stories to toilet activities.. well, if that's your literary yardstick, no way are you ever going to appreciate these works and you should move on. As Murakami wrote elsewhere: If you can't understand without an explanation, you won't understand with an explanation. I'm saying that these pieces are subtle and nuanced, and you need to be receptive to that in order to enjoy them. Just like with Japanese food. Racy, violent, horrific stories, they ain't.

As for the narration on this recording, yes it is by a Japanese person whose English seems great but not perfect, with some slight mispronunciations here and there, odd stresses, even Western pronunciations of some Japanese words (eg: writer's name akuTAgawa instead of the correct aKUtaGAwa), and so on. But, for me it worked very well, in as much as it strengthened the idea that I was reading/listening to writing from another land where they do things very differently yet still experience the same perplexities of life as we do in the West. He also has a very melodic voice with a pleasing range of tone and without the formulaic cadences that some narrators stick to come what may. Just listen to the sample to decide.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Struggled with the narrator

Found it very difficult to focus because of the narration. Previous narrators were fabulous, why change them for a non- native English speaker?

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

Murakami , what more can I say?

As a die hard Murakami fan who has read every book he's written, I'd say I'm biased.
Having said that, I loved these short stories. Not many authors can make every single word feel rightly placed - Murakami does.
Thank you Murakami.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

like meeting a friend in Japan

I saw some criticism of the narrator, and my first impression was the same but then I wondered if I should think about the book in a different way. rather than being a professional narration I thought about it more like having message someone in a bar in Osaka and them telling me these stories. once I thought it that way I started to really enjoy the book and appreciate a style of narration. the book itself is ok an interest and honest series of insight into the mind of murakami. this may not be what you want but for me it was gentle and honest and thought provoking

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

unpleasant voice

The performance was not to my liking. I like the author and loved all his books both audio and hard copies, but I find the voice of this narrator is unpleasant to my ears. Sorry about that.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Yaaaaawn.

Seems like this guy can just bang anything he wants out these days and it`ll sell just because his name`s on it. The talking monkey story is a little bit interesting, but hardly a work of genius. The rest of it is just like listening to someone ramble on about random events in their life that aren`t even that interesting. If this had been released under a different name, no-one would be saying things like, `stunning`, etc. It`d probably just sink without trace like the turd you let go this morning. Oh, and the narrator, what`s the opposite of mellifluous? Well, that`s his reading style.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Meh at best

I enjoy many of Murakami’s novels, but this is disappointing. This is just as boring as they come, and isn’t helped by the narration.
I think one, maybe two story’s are worth a re listen.

Ignore all the 5 star reviews of amazing work, they are either fake or are blinded by their own infatuation

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Not Murakami’s best work

I love Murakami’s works. Maybe that’s why I expected more - stories leave you thinking there must be more to this plot.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!